The Dee Why Civic Centre is being considered for addition to the NSW Heritage Register. It will join a growing list of over 1,000 sites protected in the last five years, including a dinosaur statue, a horse trough, and even road guttering.
In the past five years, local councils across NSW have added various unusual sites to their heritage registers. These include Ploddy the Dinosaur, a roadside attraction near the Australian Reptile Park, a section of kerb and guttering in Maclean, and a horse trough in the Blue Mountains.
This trend has sparked debate about whether councils use heritage listings to prevent new housing developments. The Dee Why Civic Centre, constructed in the Brutalist style in 1973 when Warringah Council relocated from Brookvale, is among the buildings considered for heritage protection.
Councils Accused of Using Heritage Listings to Block Development
Sydney YIMBY, an organisation advocating for increased housing in Sydney, argues that many recently listed sites are “unremarkable” and that councils are using heritage protection to halt housing growth. They believe heritage listings should be reserved for truly unique places, and councils should focus on meeting current housing needs.
Jim Carroll, strata chair for the Ithaca Gardens tower in Elizabeth Bay, which the City of Sydney Council is proposing to list, expressed concern that heritage status would impose delays, costs, and restrictions on unit owners.
Heritage Protection Vital for Preserving History
However, others argue that heritage protection is crucial for preserving history. Cheryl Bates, Sydney branch president of the National Trust, emphasises the importance of respecting heritage as a significant part of our story, particularly in rapidly changing areas like Parramatta.
She points out that some heritage in Parramatta is over 200 years old and that the area has already seen the destruction of historic sites.
Balancing Heritage with Housing Needs
The Property Council of Australia believes heritage laws must balance current housing demands. NSW Planning Minister Paul Scully agrees, stating that councils should not use heritage protection to avoid their responsibility to increase housing supply. He emphasised that each local government area has a housing target to meet.
Published Date 22-Jan-2025